Caffeine · per 200 mg
Vivarin vs Vitamatic caffeine pills
Vitamatic costs 89% less per 200 mg than Vivarin: $0.04 vs $0.37. At one serving a day that is $14.60 a year instead of $136.66, $122.06 less.
Popular brand
Vivarin
VIVARIN · 16 Tablets
- Per serving
- $0.37 per 200 mg
- A year, one serving a day
- $136.66
- Container
- $5.99 at Vivarin
No. 1 cheapest on our list89% less
Vitamatic
Caffeine · 200 mg · 250 Tablets
- Per serving
- $0.04 per 200 mg
- A year, one serving a day
- $14.60
- Container
- $9.99 at Vitacost
Buy links are affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes the order. How we make money
Side by side
| Detail | Vivarin | Vitamatic |
|---|---|---|
| Price per 200 mg | $0.37 | $0.04 |
| A year, one serving a day | $136.66 | $14.60 |
| Container price | $5.99 at Vivarin | $9.99 at Vitacost |
| In the container | 3.2g caffeine | 50g caffeine |
| Servings of 200 mg | 16 | 250 |
| Serving on the label | 200 mg | 200 mg |
| Form | Tablets | Tablets |
| Third-party testing | Not listed | Not listed |
| Price checked | Every day | Every day |
Tested means the product is in the testing program's own database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). Not listed means we didn't find it there, not that it failed a test.
The verdict
Vitamatic costs 89% less per 200 mg than Vivarin: $0.04 vs $0.37. At one serving a day that is $14.60 a year instead of $136.66, $122.06 less.
We didn't find either one in a third-party testing program's database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). That doesn't mean either one failed a test.
Vitamatic costs more at checkout ($9.99 vs $5.99) because the container holds more: 250 servings of 200 mg against 16.
We compare price on the same dose. Taste, mixing, other ingredients and how a product suits you are yours to judge, so read both labels before you switch.
The cheapest caffeine pills today
Best value. Lowest price per serving on this list.
Vitamatic Caffeine · 200 mg · 250 TabletsChecked less than an hour ago
$0.04 per 200 mg89% less than Vivarin per 200 mg
BuySave me money at Vitacost (opens in a new tab)- BulkSupplements Caffeine Capsules · 500 Gelatin Capsules - 200mg Serving
Checked less than an hour ago
$0.048 per 200 mg87% less than Vivarin per 200 mg
BuySave me money at BulkSupplements (opens in a new tab) Sale · 35% off. Piping Rock is running a sale on this size.
Piping Rock Caffeine Plus Green Tea · 220 mg · 300 TabletsChecked less than an hour ago
$0.053 per 200 mg86% less than Vivarin per 200 mg
BuySave me money at Piping Rock (opens in a new tab)
Cheaper alternatives to Vivarin caffeineSee the full caffeine list
Get an email when caffeine gets cheaper
Email me when products on this list get cheaper per serving. Only price drops, a stop link in every email. We never sell your address. TikTok's ad pixel may receive a hashed copy to measure our ads unless you opt out. For people 18 and older. Privacy policy · Opt out
Questions
Is Vitamatic cheaper than Vivarin?
Vitamatic costs 89% less per 200 mg than Vivarin: $0.04 vs $0.37. Both prices are checked every day, and this page changes when they do.
Are Vivarin and Vitamatic the same caffeine pills?
Both are on our pills list: Vivarin as tablets, Vitamatic as tablets. We compare the labeled amount of the active ingredient, priced per 200 mg, not taste, other ingredients or quality. Prices shown per 200 mg of caffeine. Tablets and capsules only. Gum and pre-workout are different forms.
Is Vivarin or Vitamatic third-party tested?
We didn't find either one in a third-party testing program's database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). That doesn't mean either one failed a test.
How is the price per 200 mg worked out?
We divide the container price by how many 200 mg servings the label's amount makes. Vivarin: $5.99 ÷ 16 servings of 200 mg. Vitamatic: $9.99 ÷ 250 servings of 200 mg. Store prices can change at checkout.
More caffeine head-to-heads
- Eu Natural vs Nutricost caffeine with L-theanineNutricost costs 84% less per 200 mg than Eu Natural: $0.13 vs $0.83.
- Sports Research vs Nutricost caffeine with L-theanineNutricost costs 83% less per 200 mg than Sports Research: $0.13 vs $0.77.
Caffeine buying guides
- Caffeine and L-theanine: dose, ratio, and costWhy caffeine is paired with L-theanine, the doses and ratios used in studies, what the research found for attention, and combo pills vs separate pills.
- Best caffeine pills 2026: cheapest per 200 mgCaffeine pills ranked by price per 200 mg, with the cheapest tablets and capsules, how they compare with Vivarin and coffee, and the FDA's 400 mg daily limit.
- Caffeine pills vs coffee: cost per 200 mg, and why 100 mg may be betterA 200 mg caffeine pill costs a few cents; the same caffeine from a coffee shop costs dollars. Pills vs coffee, 100 vs 200 mg, and the 400 mg daily limit.
We show prices. We don't sell the products or tell you what to take. How we compare · Disclaimer