Melatonin · per 1 mg
Natrol vs Piping Rock melatonin gummies
Piping Rock costs 83% less per 1 mg than Natrol: $0.005 vs $0.031. At one serving a day that is $1.93 a year instead of $11.21, $9.28 less.
Popular brand
Natrol
Melatonin Gummies · 140 ct
- Per serving
- $0.031 per 1 mg
- A year, one serving a day
- $11.21
- Container
- $21.49 at Natrol
No. 1 cheapest on our list83% less
Piping Rock
Melatonin (Blackberry) Gummies · 5 mg · 120 Gummies
- Per serving
- $0.005 per 1 mg
- A year, one serving a day
- $1.93
- Container
- $1.59 at Piping Rock
Buy links are affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes the order. How we make money
Side by side
| Detail | Natrol | Piping Rock |
|---|---|---|
| Price per 1 mg | $0.031 | $0.005 |
| A year, one serving a day | $11.21 | $1.93 |
| Container price | $21.49 at Natrol | $1.59 at Piping Rock |
| In the container | 700mg melatonin | 300mg melatonin |
| Servings of 1 mg | 700 | 300 |
| Serving on the label | 10 mg | 5 mg |
| Form | Gummies | Gummies |
| Third-party testing | Not listed | Not listed |
| Price checked | Every day | Every day |
Tested means the product is in the testing program's own database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). Not listed means we didn't find it there, not that it failed a test.
The verdict
Piping Rock costs 83% less per 1 mg than Natrol: $0.005 vs $0.031. At one serving a day that is $1.93 a year instead of $11.21, $9.28 less.
We didn't find either one in a third-party testing program's database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). That doesn't mean either one failed a test.
The labels use different servings (Natrol: 10 mg, Piping Rock: 5 mg), so both are priced on the same 1 mg.
We compare price on the same dose. Taste, mixing, other ingredients and how a product suits you are yours to judge, so read both labels before you switch.
The cheapest melatonin gummies today
Best value. Lowest price per serving on this list.
Piping Rock Melatonin (Blackberry) Gummies · 5 mg · 120 GummiesChecked less than an hour ago
$0.005 per 1 mg83% less than Natrol per 1 mg
BuySave me money at Piping Rock (opens in a new tab)- Micro Ingredients Melatonin Gummies · Blackberry Cherry
Checked less than an hour ago
$0.02 per 1 mg35% less than Natrol per 1 mg
BuySave me money at Micro Ingredients (opens in a new tab) - Vitamatic Vegan Melatonin Gummies, Natural Strawberry · 10 mg · 60 Gummies
Checked less than an hour ago
$0.02 per 1 mg35% less than Natrol per 1 mg
BuySave me money at Vitacost (opens in a new tab)
Cheaper alternatives to Natrol melatonin (gummies)See the full melatonin list
Get an email when melatonin gets cheaper
Email me when products on this list get cheaper per serving. Only price drops, a stop link in every email. We never sell your address. TikTok's ad pixel may receive a hashed copy to measure our ads unless you opt out. For people 18 and older. Privacy policy · Opt out
Questions
Is Piping Rock cheaper than Natrol?
Piping Rock costs 83% less per 1 mg than Natrol: $0.005 vs $0.031. Both prices are checked every day, and this page changes when they do.
Are Natrol and Piping Rock the same melatonin gummies?
Both are on our gummies list: Natrol as gummies, Piping Rock as gummies. We compare the labeled amount of the active ingredient, priced per 1 mg, not taste, other ingredients or quality. Prices shown per 1 mg of melatonin. That is a unit for comparing prices, not a recommendation of what to take.
Is Natrol or Piping Rock third-party tested?
We didn't find either one in a third-party testing program's database (NSF, USP, Informed Sport or Choice, IFOS). That doesn't mean either one failed a test.
How is the price per 1 mg worked out?
We divide the container price by how many 1 mg servings the label's amount makes. Natrol: $21.49 ÷ 700 servings of 1 mg. Piping Rock: $1.59 ÷ 300 servings of 1 mg. Store prices can change at checkout.
More melatonin head-to-heads
- Natrol vs Micro Ingredients melatonin tablets and capsulesMicro Ingredients costs 84% less per 1 mg than Natrol: $0.003 vs $0.019.
- Nature Made vs Micro Ingredients melatonin tablets and capsulesMicro Ingredients costs 83% less per 1 mg than Nature Made: $0.003 vs $0.017.
Melatonin buying guides
- Melatonin for jet lag: dose and timing that actually workA Cochrane review found 0.5 to 5 mg of melatonin at destination bedtime reduced jet lag after long eastward flights. When to take it, what dose, and the cost.
- Melatonin dose: why 0.5–1 mg often beats 10 mg (and the hangover)Studies used 0.3 to 5 mg, yet stores stock 10 mg. Why high doses cause next-day grogginess, what gummy tests found, and how to buy a small dose cheaply.
We show prices. We don't sell the products or tell you what to take. How we compare · Disclaimer